Most entrepreneurs assume that registering a company means they own it. They incorporate, they are appointed as director, and they get to work — never questioning whether the registration itself gave them any ownership at all.
It did not.
Ownership of a company is not acquired by registration. It is acquired through shares. And this distinction — simple as it sounds — is one of the most consequential things a business owner in South Africa can understand.
This article explains the difference between a director and a shareholder, why it matters, and what you need to do to ensure your position in your own company is correctly documented.
A director is a person appointed to manage and run a company. Under the Companies Act 71 of 2008, directors carry specific duties — to act in good faith, in the best interests of the company, and with the care and skill that can reasonably be expected of someone in their position.
Being a director gives you authority to manage. It does not give you ownership.
A shareholder is a person who holds shares in a company. Shares represent ownership. When a company generates profit and declares dividends, those dividends are paid to shareholders. When a company is sold, it is the shareholders who receive the proceeds. Voting rights at shareholder meetings belong to shareholders.
Ownership flows from shares — not from a directorship.
In most small and owner-managed businesses in South Africa, the founder is both the director and the sole shareholder. They manage the business and they own it. Because both roles are held by the same person, the distinction is easy to overlook.
But these are two legally separate roles. They can be held by the same person, or by different people entirely.
A director without shares manages the company but owns nothing in it. This is common when a business owner appoints a trusted employee or professional as a director but retains all the shares themselves.
It also happens unintentionally — when a founder incorporates a company, is appointed as director, but fails to ensure that shares are properly issued to them. They run the company. On paper, they do not own it.
A shareholder without a directorship holds an ownership stake but plays no role in managing the business. Silent investors and sleeping partners often hold shares without any involvement in day-to-day operations.
The difference between being a director and being a shareholder has practical consequences across several areas of business and personal life.
Dividends. Profits distributed from a company are paid to shareholders, not directors. A director who holds no shares receives no dividends, regardless of how long they have been running the business.
Selling the business. When a company is sold, the transaction involves the transfer of shares. If you do not hold shares, you have nothing to sell — even if you built the business from the ground up.
Estate planning. When you die, your shares form part of your estate and can be left to beneficiaries in your will. A directorship cannot be inherited. If your shares were never correctly issued or documented, your estate may have no stake in the business you spent years building.
Co-founder disputes. In disputes between co-founders, shareholding determines voting power and decision-making authority. A co-founder who holds more shares can, in certain circumstances, outvote and remove a director. Understanding your shareholding position is essential before any dispute escalates.
Divorce and insolvency. Shares are an asset and can be relevant in divorce proceedings or insolvency. A directorship is not.
An entrepreneur has an idea, registers a company, is appointed as its director, and gets to work. Years pass. The business grows. Then something goes wrong — a dispute with a co-founder, a divorce, or the death of a partner — and it emerges that the shares were never properly issued or the shareholding was never formally documented.
The person who built the business cannot prove they own it.
This is not a rare situation. It is one of the most common structural problems we encounter in small and medium-sized businesses across Johannesburg.
There is a further step that many business owners are still unaware of. Since 24 May 2023, following the General Laws (Anti-Money Laundering and Combating Terrorism Financing) Amendment Act 22 of 2022, every company registered with CIPC (co-operatives excepted) must file a beneficial ownership declaration identifying the natural persons who ultimately own or control the company.
The timing requirements are:
Since 1 April 2024, CIPC has applied a hard stop: a company cannot file its annual return until the beneficial ownership filing is up to date. Non-compliance can attract an administrative penalty, a compliance notice, being barred from transacting with CIPC, and ultimately referral for deregistration.
This obligation reinforces the central point of this article. Beneficial ownership is about shares and control, not directorship. If your shareholding was never properly issued and recorded, you may find you cannot accurately complete the filing — and the gap in your own company records becomes a compliance problem as well as a legal one.
When incorporating a company, ensure that shares are formally issued and recorded in the company’s securities register. If there are multiple founders or investors, document the shareholding structure clearly from the outset.
A shareholders’ agreement is strongly recommended wherever two or more people hold shares in a company. It governs how decisions are made, what happens when a shareholder wants to exit, and how disputes are resolved — before those situations arise.
Review your company’s share structure periodically, particularly when the business grows, takes on new investors, or when personal circumstances change.
HvS Attorneys advises entrepreneurs, startups and owner-managed businesses across Johannesburg on company structures, shareholding and corporate governance.
If you are unsure whether your position in your company is correctly documented — or if you are starting a new business and want to get the structure right from the beginning — contact us for a consultation.
📩 enquiries@hvslegal.co.za 🌐 www.hvslegal.co.za
This article is intended for general information purposes and does not constitute legal advice. For advice specific to your situation, contact HvS Attorneys for a consultation.
Related reading:
Once your company is correctly structured, understand your obligations as an employer: how to dismiss an employee fairly in South Africa.
Companies that lease business premises should review what to include in a commercial lease agreement.
Business owners should also have a will that addresses their shares: do I need a will?
Effective Date: 1 January 2025 · Last Updated: April 2025
HvS Attorneys (“we”, “us”, “our”) is committed to protecting the privacy of all individuals who interact with our website, engage our services, or submit information through our digital platforms. This Privacy Policy explains how we collect, use, store, and protect your personal information.
We may collect the following categories of personal information:
We use your personal information to respond to enquiries, schedule and conduct consultations, provide legal services where an attorney-client relationship has been established, comply with legal and professional obligations, and improve the functionality of our website.
We process personal information on the basis of consent (where provided), the necessity to fulfil a contractual or pre-contractual obligation, our legitimate interests in operating a professional legal practice, and our legal obligations under South African law.
We do not sell, rent, or trade your personal information. We may share information with third-party service providers who assist us in operating our practice (such as scheduling platforms or IT service providers), subject to appropriate confidentiality obligations. We may also disclose information where required by law or professional regulatory requirements.
We implement reasonable technical and organisational measures to protect your personal information from unauthorised access, loss, misuse, or alteration.
We retain personal information for as long as necessary to fulfil the purposes for which it was collected, to comply with legal obligations, or to resolve disputes. Client files are retained in accordance with the requirements of the Legal Practice Act and applicable professional rules.
You have the right to request access to, correction of, or deletion of your personal information held by us, subject to applicable legal and professional obligations. Requests may be directed to enquiries@hvslegal.co.za.
Our website may use cookies or similar technologies to improve user experience and collect anonymised usage data. You may adjust your browser settings to disable cookies, although this may affect certain functionality.
For any privacy-related queries, please contact us at enquiries@hvslegal.co.za or +27 10 143 0185.
In terms of the Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013 (POPIA) · Effective: April 2025
HvS Attorneys
35 Fricker Road, Illovo, Sandton, Johannesburg
Email: enquiries@hvslegal.co.za
Tel: +27 10 143 0185
This notice is provided in compliance with POPIA to inform you of your rights regarding the processing of your personal information by HvS Attorneys as the Responsible Party.
We process personal information under POPIA on one or more of the following grounds: consent of the data subject; necessity to fulfil a contract; necessity to comply with a legal obligation; or legitimate interests of the Responsible Party.
In terms of POPIA, you have the right to be notified that your personal information is being processed; request access to personal information we hold about you; request correction or deletion of inaccurate or outdated personal information; object to the processing of your personal information; and lodge a complaint with the Information Regulator of South Africa.
Personal information may be processed or stored using third-party service providers whose infrastructure may be located outside South Africa. Where this occurs, we ensure appropriate safeguards are in place in accordance with POPIA.
The Information Officer of HvS Attorneys is the principal attorney. Requests relating to personal information may be directed to enquiries@hvslegal.co.za.
Should you wish to lodge a complaint, you may contact the Information Regulator of South Africa at inforeg@justice.gov.za or visit www.justice.gov.za/inforeg.
Submission of an enquiry form or contact via this website does not constitute the establishment of an attorney-client relationship. A formal attorney-client relationship is only established upon written confirmation by HvS Attorneys.