About Practice Areas How We Work Attorney FAQ Articles Contact Book a Consultation

Practice Areas

Litigation & Dispute Resolution

Clear advice on your legal prospects and decisive action when a dispute requires formal resolution.

When a dispute cannot be resolved informally, you need clear advice on your position and an attorney prepared to act decisively. HvS Attorneys provides both, from an honest assessment of your prospects to full litigation and alternative dispute resolution.

We handle civil litigation, debt recovery, and commercial disputes in the Magistrate's Court and High Court. Where appropriate, we advise on and facilitate mediation and arbitration as faster, cost-effective alternatives to litigation.

What We Cover

  • Civil Litigation
  • Debt Recovery
  • Commercial Disputes
  • Mediation & Arbitration
  • ADR

Who This Is For

Businesses and individuals facing disputes that require formal legal resolution, from debt recovery to commercial and civil litigation.

Litigation is a tool, not an outcome. It is slow, it is expensive, and winning does not mean being made whole. The useful question at the start of a dispute is not whether you are right, it is whether suing is the best available way of getting what you want.

HvS Attorneys advises on and conducts civil litigation for clients in Illovo, Sandton, Rosebank and across Johannesburg, in contractual disputes, debt recovery, property and rental matters, and commercial disagreements between businesses or shareholders.

Before you issue summons

Most disputes should start with a letter of demand. It sets out what you say is owed or owing, on what basis, and by when. A properly drafted demand resolves a meaningful proportion of matters without litigation, and where it does not, it establishes your position on the record and often triggers the interruption of prescription through an acknowledgement of debt.

Certain claims require a specific statutory notice before action, and credit agreements have their own pre-litigation requirements. Issuing summons without the right prior step is a way of losing time rather than saving it.

The three-year clock

An ordinary debt, whether it arises from a contract or from harm someone has caused you, prescribes after three years under the Prescription Act 68 of 1969. Once it has prescribed the debt is extinguished, not merely unenforceable. Prescription is interrupted by service of process or by the debtor acknowledging liability, which is one reason a written acknowledgement of debt has value even from a debtor who cannot pay today.

Claims against certain public bodies carry shorter notice periods, so a claim involving an organ of state needs attention sooner rather than later.

Which court hears your matter

The value of the claim usually determines the forum:

Forum matters commercially as well as procedurally, because costs scales differ. Running a R250 000 claim in the High Court when the Regional Court had jurisdiction is a decision that shows up in the costs order.

How an action runs

A trial action begins with summons and particulars of claim. The defendant enters appearance and delivers a plea, and may counterclaim. The parties then exchange documents through discovery, which is frequently where the real strength of each case becomes visible, and the matter is set down for trial.

Where the dispute is about law rather than disputed facts, application proceedings on affidavit are usually faster and cheaper. Choosing the wrong procedure is a common and expensive error, because a factual dispute raised on affidavit can see the application dismissed or referred to oral evidence.

What costs orders actually recover

Costs generally follow the event, meaning the losing party is ordered to contribute to the winner’s costs. It is important to understand what that contribution is. A party and party costs order is assessed by the court against a fixed tariff and commonly recovers only a portion of what you have actually paid your own attorney. An attorney and client order recovers more, and is not the default.

We say this at the outset rather than at the end. A successful outcome that costs more than it recovers is a poor result, and sometimes the honest advice is not to litigate.

Mediation and arbitration

Many commercial contracts require mediation or arbitration before court proceedings, and those clauses are enforceable. Even where no clause applies, mediation is usually faster and cheaper than trial, and it allows commercial outcomes a court cannot order, such as continued trading on revised terms.

Arbitration offers privacy and a decision from someone with relevant expertise, with limited rights of appeal. Whether that limitation is an advantage depends on which side of the award you expect to be.

How we work

The first 45 minutes cost R1 200 and include up to 10 pages read in advance, which in a dispute usually means the agreement and the correspondence. That fee is credited against work instructed within 30 days. Defined steps such as a letter of demand are fixed-fee and quoted in writing, and longer matters bill by stage so you are never handed an open-ended account. This firm does not act on contingency.

Common questions

How long do I have to bring a claim?

Generally three years, whether the debt arises from a contract or from harm someone has caused you. Once prescription runs the debt is extinguished. Claims against organs of state have shorter notice requirements.

Do I have to send a letter of demand first?

Not in every case, but it is usually the right first step, and some claims do require a statutory notice beforehand. A demand resolves many disputes without litigation and sets out your position on the record.

Which court will my matter go to?

Usually the value decides. Up to R200 000 is the District Court, R200 000 to R400 000 the Regional Court, and above that the High Court. The choice affects the costs you can recover.

If I win, does the other side pay my legal fees?

Partly. Costs usually follow the event, but a standard party and party costs order is assessed by the court against a fixed tariff and typically recovers only a portion of what you have actually paid.

How long does litigation take?

Defended matters are measured in months at best and often years, depending on how quickly the court can give dates and how hard the dispute is fought. Applications on affidavit are generally quicker than trial actions.

Should I mediate instead?

Often yes. Mediation is faster and cheaper, and it can produce commercial outcomes a court cannot order. Some contracts make it compulsory before litigation, and those clauses are enforceable.

★★★★★5.010 Google reviews

Enquire About Litigation & Dispute Resolution

Send us the details of your matter and we will respond directly. There is no charge for an initial enquiry.

Contact HvS Attorneys

We use these details to respond to your enquiry and to assess whether we can assist. They are received by HvS Attorneys only and are not shared with third parties. Supplying them is voluntary, but we cannot respond without them. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. See our Privacy Policy and POPIA Notice.

WhatsApp Us
Our office line (010 143 0185) is temporarily down. Please email enquiries@hvslegal.co.za or WhatsApp 065 074 8264.