Most property disputes that reach this firm were avoidable. A lease that was never reduced to writing. A deposit that was never invested. An outgoing inspection that nobody arranged. By the time the dispute is live, the question is no longer what the parties meant, it is what can be proved.
HvS Attorneys acts for landlords, tenants, property investors and managing agents in Illovo, Sandton, Rosebank, Hyde Park and across Johannesburg. We draft and review leases, advise on rights and obligations, recover arrear rental, and run eviction proceedings where they become necessary.
Lease agreements
A residential lease does not have to be in writing to be binding. The Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999 says so directly, and it also says that a landlord must reduce the lease to writing if the tenant asks. In practice an unwritten lease is a dispute waiting to happen, because the terms that matter most, being escalation, the notice period, who maintains what, and what the deposit covers, are the terms nobody can later recall the same way.
We draft leases that set those terms out properly, and we review leases that have already been presented to you, before you sign rather than after.
Deposits and the rules that cannot be contracted out of
Deposit disputes are the most common rental matter we see, and most of them turn on rules the parties did not know were compulsory.
A deposit on a dwelling must be invested in an interest-bearing account with a financial institution. The interest belongs to the tenant, at a rate that may not be less than the rate on a savings account. During the lease a tenant may ask the landlord in writing for proof of the interest accrued, and the landlord must provide it. Where a managing agent holds the deposit, it sits in that agent’s trust account, and the Property Practitioners Act 22 of 2019 applies in addition.
None of this can be signed away. The Act says these standard provisions may not be waived by either the tenant or the landlord, so a clause in a lease purporting to do so does not assist the party relying on it.
Refund periods depend on what happened at the end of the lease:
- Seven days from expiry, where nothing is owing, with no deduction or set off
- Fourteen days from restoration of the dwelling, where the landlord has applied the deposit to amounts the tenant owes
- Twenty one days from expiry, where the tenant did not respond to the landlord’s request for an inspection
Inspections, and what a landlord loses by skipping one
The Act requires a joint incoming inspection before the tenant moves in, and a joint outgoing inspection in the three days before the lease expires.
The consequence of skipping the outgoing inspection falls on the landlord, and it is severe. Where the landlord fails to inspect in the tenant’s presence, the dwelling is deemed to be in a good and proper state of repair, the landlord has no further claim against the tenant, and the full deposit plus interest must be refunded. Landlords lose otherwise good damages claims on this point regularly.
Ending a lease
Where a tenant stays on after expiry with the landlord’s express or tacit consent, and there is no fresh written lease, the parties are treated as having entered a periodic lease on the same terms, terminable on at least one month’s written notice. Holding over is therefore not automatically unlawful occupation, which matters a great deal if eviction is being contemplated.
Evictions
A landlord may not simply repossess. Repossession requires a court order, and residential evictions are governed by the Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998, which requires proper notice and a court satisfied that eviction is just and equitable. Changing locks, cutting services or removing a tenant’s possessions is not a shortcut, it creates a second dispute on top of the first.
We advise on whether the grounds are sound before proceedings are issued, and we conduct the application where they are.
Commercial leases are a different regime
The Rental Housing Act applies to dwellings. It does not govern commercial premises, so the deposit, inspection and refund rules above do not apply to a shop, office or warehouse lease. Those are governed by the common law and the lease itself, with the Consumer Protection Act applying to some tenants and not others.
This distinction gets missed often, including in template leases downloaded online. If you are letting or taking commercial space, the lease is doing all the work, which is why it is worth getting right.
How we work
Bring the lease. Up to 10 pages are read beforehand, and the consultation runs 45 minutes at R1 200, credited in full if you instruct us within 30 days. You receive a written fee proposal before any work starts.
Common questions
Does my lease have to be in writing?
No. A residential lease is binding whether or not it is written down. A tenant may require the landlord to reduce it to writing, and a written lease must contain certain information, including the deposit amount, the rental and the notice period.
Is my landlord required to pay me interest on my deposit?
Yes, for a dwelling. The deposit must be held in an interest-bearing account and the interest belongs to you. You may ask for written proof of the interest accrued during the lease, and the landlord must provide it.
How long does a landlord have to refund my deposit?
Seven days from expiry where nothing is owed, fourteen days from restoration of the property where deductions are made, and twenty one days where you did not respond to a request for an inspection.
What happens if no outgoing inspection is done?
If the landlord fails to inspect in your presence, the property is deemed to be in good repair, the landlord has no further claim, and the full deposit and interest must be refunded.
Can a landlord evict me without a court order?
No. Repossession requires an order of court, and residential evictions must follow the PIE Act. Lockouts and disconnections are not lawful alternatives.
Do these deposit rules apply to my commercial lease?
No. The Rental Housing Act covers dwellings only. A commercial lease is governed by the common law and its own terms.
Written by Hyran van Schalkwyk, B.Soc.Sci (cum laude), LLB. Admitted attorney, Legal Practice Council 104504.
Last reviewed 19 October 2026