Most commercial disputes we are asked to fix began as a document nobody wanted to pay for. A supply arrangement agreed over email. A shareholders agreement copied from another company. A suretyship signed without reading it. The cost of settling the dispute is almost always a multiple of what the document would have cost.
HvS Attorneys acts for SMEs, founders, directors and shareholders in Illovo, Sandton, Rosebank and across Johannesburg. We draft and review commercial agreements, structure shareholder arrangements, advise directors on their exposure, and recover what is owed to you.
Commercial contracts
South African law enforces most contracts whether or not they are in writing, which is precisely why so many businesses discover too late that the terms they thought were agreed are not the terms a court will find. Writing does not make a contract valid, it makes it provable.
Two common business documents are different, and must be in writing to have any force at all. A suretyship, which is a personal guarantee for someone else’s debt, is void unless its terms are in a written document signed by the surety, under section 6 of the General Law Amendment Act 50 of 1956. A sale of land must be in writing and signed by the parties, under the Alienation of Land Act 68 of 1981. Directors regularly sign personal suretyships for company debt without appreciating that they have stepped outside the company’s limited liability.
We draft supply, distribution, service and consulting agreements, and we review what has been put in front of you before signature rather than after.
Shareholders agreements and the trap in section 15(7)
If your company has more than one shareholder and no shareholders agreement, the default position of the Companies Act 71 of 2008 governs what happens when one of you wants out, dies, or stops contributing. That default rarely matches what the founders assumed.
Where an agreement does exist, there is a structural point that catches people out. Under section 15(7), a shareholders agreement must be consistent with the Act and with the company’s Memorandum of Incorporation, and any provision inconsistent with either is void to the extent of the inconsistency. The transitional protection for agreements predating the Act expired on 30 April 2013, so it applies without qualification now.
The practical consequence is that a carefully negotiated shareholders agreement can be silently overridden by a standard MOI nobody read, often the template lodged at registration. The two documents have to be drafted as a pair, which is how we approach them.
Directors and personal exposure
Directors often assume that incorporation ends their personal risk. It does not. The Act codifies directors’ duties, requiring a director to act in good faith and for a proper purpose, in the best interests of the company, and with the degree of care, skill and diligence reasonably expected of someone carrying out that role.
Separate provisions deal with a director’s personal financial interest in a matter before the board, and the Act prohibits carrying on business recklessly or with gross negligence. A director who contravenes the Act can be held liable for loss resulting from that contravention.
We advise on board decisions before they are taken, which is considerably cheaper than defending them afterwards.
Recovering what you are owed
An ordinary contractual debt prescribes after three years under the Prescription Act 68 of 1969. Once that period runs out the debt is extinguished, and no amount of correspondence revives it. The clock is interrupted by service of process or by the debtor acknowledging the debt, which is why an acknowledgement of debt is worth obtaining even where the debtor cannot pay immediately.
We issue letters of demand, obtain acknowledgements of debt, and litigate where the amount justifies it. We will also tell you when it does not.
Confidentiality and your information
A non-disclosure agreement is worth having before a discussion with a potential partner, investor or contractor, not after. A usable NDA defines what is confidential, for how long, and what happens on breach, in terms specific enough to enforce.
Separately, if your business holds personal information about customers, staff or suppliers, the Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013 applies to you regardless of size, and compliance is a question of process rather than paperwork.
Which consumer protections apply to your business
The Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008 does not apply to every transaction. It excludes juristic persons whose asset value or annual turnover exceeds the threshold set by the Minister, currently R2 million. Whether you are protected by the Act, or bound by it in dealings with your own customers, turns on which side of that threshold each party sits.
This matters commercially. Businesses regularly assert CPA rights they do not have, or ignore CPA obligations they do.
How we work
A consultation runs 45 minutes and costs R1 200, with up to 10 pages of your documents read in advance. Instruct us within 30 days and that fee comes off the work. Standard commercial documents are fixed-fee from R2 200, quoted in writing before anything begins, and businesses below the Consumer Protection Act threshold pay a reduced rate.
Common questions
Does a business contract have to be in writing?
Usually no. Most contracts are binding whether written or not. A suretyship and a sale of land are exceptions and must be in writing and signed. The practical reason to put any agreement in writing is proof, not validity.
We are two shareholders with no shareholders agreement. Does it matter?
Yes. Without one, the default rules of the Companies Act decide what happens if one of you exits, dies or disagrees, and those defaults are rarely what founders would have chosen.
Our shareholders agreement conflicts with our MOI. Which wins?
The MOI. Under section 15(7) any provision of a shareholders agreement inconsistent with the Act or the MOI is void to the extent of the inconsistency, so the two documents need to be drafted together.
Am I personally liable for my company’s debts?
Generally not, but there are real exceptions. Signing a personal suretyship is the most common. Breaching directors’ duties or trading recklessly can also expose a director personally.
How long do I have to recover a debt?
An ordinary contractual debt prescribes after three years. Service of process or a written acknowledgement of debt interrupts the running of that period.
Does the Consumer Protection Act apply to my business?
It depends on size. Juristic persons above the R2 million threshold fall outside the Act’s protection, and the answer can differ for you and for your customer in the same transaction.
Written by Hyran van Schalkwyk, B.Soc.Sci (cum laude), LLB. Admitted attorney, Legal Practice Council 104504.
Last reviewed 26 October 2026